The Difficult Conversation You're Avoiding

Nicole James • September 17, 2025

From avoidance to action: Why most 'difficult' conversations aren't actually difficult

There's a conversation you need to have. You know exactly what it is and who it's with.


You've been putting it off for days, maybe weeks. Every time you think about it, you feel a knot in your stomach. You've rehearsed it in your head dozens of times, imagining how it might go wrong.


So you delay. You hope the situation will improve on its own. You tell yourself you'll do it next week when things are less busy.


But the problem isn't getting better. It's getting worse. And now you're losing sleep over it.


Why Managers Avoid Difficult Conversations


🎭 Fear it will be confrontational You imagine shouting, tears, or awkward silences. You worry about damaging the relationship or making the person defensive.

🤷 Not knowing what to say You don't have a script. You're worried you'll say the wrong thing, make legal mistakes, or handle it badly.

⏰ Hoping it will resolve itself Maybe they'll realise the problem and fix it without you having to say anything. Maybe they'll leave. Maybe it will just go away.

😰 Fear of making it worse What if they get upset? What if they argue back? What if other people find out? What if it affects team morale?


The Reality About Difficult Conversations


Most difficult conversations aren't difficult.


They're uncomfortable, yes. But confrontational? Rarely.


Often, the employee knows there's an issue. They might even be relieved you're finally addressing it. They certainly respect you more for having the courage to lead.


The conversation you're avoiding is rarely as difficult as you think it will be. But avoiding it definitely makes everything worse.


How to Have the Conversation


📊 Start with facts, not feelings "You've been late four times this week" not "You seem to have a time management problem." "You interrupted Sarah three times in yesterday's meeting" not "You're being disrespectful." "Your report was submitted two days after the deadline" not "You don't seem to care about deadlines."

Facts are hard to argue with. Feelings and interpretations create defensiveness.


🎯 Focus on impact, not intent "When you're late, it delays the team meeting and affects everyone's schedule" not "You don't care about the team." "When reports are late, it delays the client presentation" not "You're letting everyone down." "When people are interrupted, they can't contribute their ideas properly" not "You're being rude."

You don't know their intent, but you can see the impact. Focus on what you can observe and measure.


✅ Be clear about expectations "I need you to be here by 9am every day" not "Try to be more punctual." "In meetings, please let people finish their point before responding" not "Be more respectful." "Reports must be submitted by the deadline we agree" not "Try to be more organised."

Vague requests get vague results. Specific expectations get specific changes.


Three Steps to Have Any Difficult Conversation


🗓️ Schedule it properly Don't ambush them. "Can we have a chat about punctuality? Are you free for 15 minutes this afternoon?" gives them time to prepare mentally.


🎯 Keep it focused One issue per conversation. Don't bring up everything they've ever done wrong. Deal with the specific behaviour that needs to change.


👂 Listen to their response There might be something you don't know. Personal issues, work challenges, or misunderstandings. Listen first, then work together on solutions.


What Usually Happens


In most cases, the person will:

  • Acknowledge the issue
  • Explain any circumstances you weren't aware of
  • Agree to change the behaviour
  • Thank you for being direct rather than letting it fester


The dramatic confrontation you imagined rarely happens. What you get instead is clarity, respect, and usually quick improvement.


The Cost of Continuing to Avoid It


Every day you don't have the conversation:

  • The behaviour continues or gets worse
  • Your stress increases
  • Other team members notice your inaction
  • Your credibility as a leader decreases
  • The conversation becomes harder to have

The longer you wait, the bigger the issue becomes and the more difficult the conversation actually gets.


The Reality Check

You're not paid to avoid difficult conversations. You're paid to have them.


Leadership isn't about being liked. It's about being effective. Sometimes that means saying things people don't want to hear.


Your team needs you to address issues. They need to see that standards matter and that poor behaviour has consequences.


The conversation you're avoiding right now? It's probably not as difficult as you think.

But it's definitely necessary.


Schedule it. Have it. Move on.


Your team - and your peace of mind - will thank you for it.

 



Got a difficult conversation you've been putting off? The longer you wait, the harder it gets and the more it affects your credibility as a leader. If you need help planning your next steps then send me a DM. 


By Nicole James October 28, 2025
(And Why You're Wrong)
By Nicole James October 8, 2025
The Five Reasons Your Best People Are Walking Out (And What To Do About It)
By Nicole James September 24, 2025
A Simple Four-Skill Framework That Delivers Real Results
By Nicole James August 19, 2025
How to protect your business from illegal working fines
By Nicole James July 31, 2025
Top tips to prepare for changes to sickness absence in April 2026
By Nicole James July 25, 2025
Big changes are coming for UK businesses with the introduction of the Employment Rights Bill. And the ones that prepare properly will have a significant advantage. Employment tribunal claims rose 23% last year. There are 45,000 open cases right now - a 32% increase on last year. The system is buckling under pressure. The heat is on employers to get people practices right and if they don't the commercial implications in terms of time and cost are significant. The Bill adds additional stress to businesses that are already finding it hard. But here's the good news: the government has given you more time to prepare. The biggest change - day-one unfair dismissal rights - won't kick in until 2027. The businesses that use this time to build proper people management systems will thrive. Those that don't will be at serious risk of costly claims and poor staff commitment. You have time to get this right. But only if you start acting now. The Numbers That Should Worry You 📈 Tribunal claims are exploding: Unfair dismissal: 22% of all claims Discrimination claims: 30% of total cases (up 15% in one quarter) Disability discrimination: up 28% in Q1 2025 alone Average unfair dismissal award: £13,749 💰 Immediate costs hitting now: National Insurance up from 13.8% to 15% Statutory sick pay rises to £118.75 per week New neonatal care leave: 12 weeks paid Fire and rehire failures: 25% compensation uplift (up to 112.5 days' pay) These aren't just statistics. They're real costs hitting real businesses right now. What Changes When (And Why It Matters) The government is taking a phased approach, with three key implementation dates: 📅 April 2026: Statutory Sick Pay reforms Protective awards double (90 to 180 days for collective redundancy breaches) Fair Work Agency established Day-one paternity and parental leave rights Trade union balloting changes 📅 October 2026: Fire and rehire restrictions Enhanced sexual harassment prevention duties Third-party harassment liability Extended tribunal claim time limits Stronger union rights and tips laws 🚨 2027 - The Big One: Day-one unfair dismissal rights Currently, employees need two years' service to claim unfair dismissal. From 2027, they can claim from day one. With unfair dismissal already representing 22% of all tribunal claims, expect this to explode. The smart businesses are using this extended timeline to build proper people management systems, not just fixing immediate problems. The People Problems You Need to Fix (But Now You Have Time to Do It Right) 🎯 Underperformers That team member who's been coasting for months? You don't need to panic, but you do need a plan. Use this time to implement proper performance management systems, not just quick fixes. ⏰ Attendance issues Persistent lateness or absence patterns? Build robust absence management procedures. You have time to do this properly, not reactively. 😤 Attitude problems Behavioural issues affecting the team? Address them systematically. Create clear behavioural expectations and consequences. 📝 Poor documentation If you can't prove your decisions were fair, you'll lose at tribunal. Use this extended timeline to build proper record-keeping systems. This isn't about rushing to fire people. It's about building systems that prevent problems and manage them fairly when they arise. Three Things You Should Start This Year 🔍 Build proper foundations Don't just patch problems - build systems. Review employment contracts, create comprehensive policies, and establish robust record-keeping. You have time to do this properly. 💪 Invest in manager development Train your managers in employment law basics, difficult conversations, and fair treatment principles. They're your first line of defence, and you now have time to develop their skills properly. 🎯 Create prevention systems Rather than just fixing current issues, build systems that prevent problems. Regular employee feedback, clear communication processes, and proactive performance management. The Business Case (It's Not Just About Compliance) Getting people management right isn't just about avoiding tribunals. Committed employees deliver: 21% higher profitability 10% increase in customer satisfaction 20% increase in sales Poor people practices cost you: Management time lost to tribunal proceedings (average 4.8 weeks per claim) Reputational damage High turnover costs Reduced productivity from everyone else The Reality Check The employment law landscape is changing, but you have more time than originally thought to prepare properly. Day-one unfair dismissal rights don't come in until 2027. But don't waste this opportunity. The businesses that use this time wisely will have a significant competitive advantage.  This isn't just about compliance. It's about building businesses that can attract, retain and motivate great people. The businesses that will succeed are those that see these changes as an opportunity to professionalise their people practices. You have time to get this right. But only if you start building proper systems now, not waiting until 2026 to panic. The question isn't whether you can afford to invest in better people management. It's whether you can afford not to. While others wait until the last minute, smart businesses are already building the people practices that will give them competitive advantage in the new employment landscape. Don't waste the extra time you've been given. Need help building robust people management systems? The businesses that start now will be way ahead of those that wait until the last minute. Need help preparing for the changes ahead? The businesses that act now will have a significant advantage over those that wait until 2026.
By Nicole James June 28, 2025
(And What To Do About It)
By Nicole James June 24, 2025
Why Getting It Right Has Never Been More Critical
By Nicole James July 9, 2024
Key new legislation being introduced by labour in 100 days
By Nicole James June 27, 2024
A guide for employers